The Weekly Bender: Is Robust-QB a Preferred Draft Strategy?

Thu Jun 5 9:55pm ET
By HOWARD BENDER
Fantasy Writer

If there’s one thing I can say after more than 30 years of playing fantasy football and over 20 years in the fantasy sports industry…

There's more than one way to skin a cat.

There's more than one way to crack an egg.

There's more than one path to the top of the mountain.

All roads lead to Rome.

Dress it up however you like, the bottom line is that there are numerous ways to win a fantasy football championship. Every road begins with the first pick of your draft, but in the spirit of a Choose Your Own Adventure book, the directions you can take afterward are virtually limitless. We’re all looking to land in the same spot – the winner’s circle – but the paths to get there can be incredibly different.

If you want to go with an anchor-RB strategy, go for it. Robust-RB? For sure. Zero-RB? Not my favorite, but yes, you can certainly forge a path toward winning if everything breaks right for you. Over the years, we’ve seen plenty of different draft strategies and while each one has its pros and cons, there are clear-cut examples out there of people winning with their preferred methodology.

What about Robust-QB in a best-ball format?

Is that even a thing? Well, if you are following the current run of drafts in the $10,000 Beat Bender Best Ball Championship, you’ll not only see it, but you could be seeing it more often than you would have even imagined. I haven’t gone through every single draft in the tournament, but in four of the drafts I’ve participated in so far, I’ve seen the strategy unfold.

Check out these four draft boards:

  1. Best Ball Beat Bender 20
  2. Best Ball Beat Bender 24
  3. Best Ball Beat Bender 50
  4. Best Ball Beat Bender 62

In each of these drafts, there has been a team that not only finished with at least four quarterbacks on their roster, but also has at least two of the top-five quarterbacks, according to recent fantasy football ADP. To do that, you need to have at least two quarterbacks within your first five picks of the draft. Doing so is an interesting strategy as you are not only ensuring yourself (more or less) of strong quarterback production each week, but you are also taking that production away from your opposition. Is it fool proof? No, of course not. Things happen. Injuries occur. But you are certainly increasing your chances of having a dominant performance at a very key position in fantasy each week while, at the same time, forcing your opponents to scramble at a position no one wants to be scrambling around for.

But what about the rest of your team build? Investing so heavily at one position means you are slighting another. Normally, you could say, “No problem, I’ll just grab an extra QB while everyone else is pushing for Brock Bowers, Trey McBride or some other tight end who goes way too early.” But in these Beat Bender leagues, it’s TE-premium (1.5 PPR), so maybe throwing away that position is the wrong move.

Before I break down and/or criticize these Robust-QB drafts, I should be fair and at least share my draft strategy. They do change from draft to draft, depending on what falls to me, but for the most part, there is a base. A foundation, if you will.

My typical game plan is to go with a heavy lean on running backs early, check out quarterbacks or maybe even tight ends available and then bulk up and basically play receiver roulette. With only two receiver spots you can play the percentages, right? Grab anywhere from six to eight receivers in a 20-round draft and only need two, maybe three, to pop off each week. That’s not something you can do at the running back position. Late-round running backs usually need an injury or two for them to move up the depth chart and see an increased workload. You find a high-volume passing offense and you could see two, three or maybe even four guys have a strong day.

Now let’s take a look at how the rest of the roster looks for a Robust-QB draft strategy.

Draft 1:

In one of the first drafts I did, the person at Pick 3 went to town on the quarterback position. Already solid with a second-round Josh Allen selection and with two strong running backs in Saquon Barkley and Kyren Williams, one would assume the wide receiver position would be the next stage of attack. But rather than follow what most would consider a solid draft plan, this person went with Jayden Daniels and Jalen Hurts in back-to-back picks. Mind blown? A little. But mind really blown when they added Jordan Love in the 13th round.

I do like the group of running backs, all things considered. D’Andre Swift, Aaron Jones and Isiah Pacheco may not be my favorites but all three will be seeing lead carries out of their respective backfields. But are Zay Flowers, an injury-prone Cooper Kupp and Vikings No. 2 Jordan Addison enough to lead the charge each week? There’s upside later on with Jack Bech and Jaylin Noel, but Adam Thielen’s days of being explosive are long gone. If he remains the security blanket for Bryce Young, then he’s got a decent floor, but the receiving corps is definitely lacking.

One thing I do really like, however, is what this drafter did with the tight end position. These drafts are TE-premium, so adding guys who are expecting decent target shares like Colston Loveland and Jake Ferguson is definitely going to be helpful in filling out the flex spots, if needed. Helpful for sure, but I’m still not sold that three top quarterbacks and a fourth from the mid-tier is the proper way to go.

Draft 2:

Based on the name, the person picking at Pick 7 is likely to be the same as the person in the previous draft. But in this one, they went a slightly different direction. They still took two elite quarterbacks early in Daniels and Hurts, but he took his foot off the gas and stayed more focused on running backs and wide receivers in the first 10 rounds. His running backs are solid and is receiving corps is much more improved, especially now that we’re hearing Aaron Rodgers is definitely going to the Steelers. I don’t think much of him, but I do like DK Metcalf with Rodgers under center a lot more than I do with Mason Rudolph.

They grabbed CJ Stroud and Jordan Love in Rounds 11 and 12 which works for me as they basically punted the tight end position here. Tyler Warren has promise, but it would be surprising to see him using more than one tight end each week. His flex spots belong to the receivers, maybe a running back. Funny enough, I think I actually like his first draft more than this one.

Draft 3:

This draft, the build was similar to what we just saw in Draft 2. Two elite QBs in Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson with two mid-tier guys in the later rounds in Love and Stroud. The name is different on the team, but they do smell similar, don’t they? Draft 1 was heavy on running backs and quarterbacks, the second one was a fairly even mix of running backs and wide receivers with two elite QBs and now this one leans a little WR-heavy with selections of Ja’Marr Chase, Garrett Wilson and Marvin Harrison Jr. all inside the first five rounds. They added a few running backs in there with Aaron Jones and Tony Pollard, but the lean back into the receivers for Kupp, Deebo Samuel and Jayden Reed give you a third way to go about a Robust-QB draft. Overall, I would say this is my second favorite of the three with Draft 1 still in the lead.

Draft 4:

By the time you are reading this, I am hoping this draft will be finished, but as of writing, we are in the 17th round, so the last few picks are still unknown. But for our exercise here, the top of the draft is what matters most and, once again, we see two elite QBs off the board in Allen and Daniels going to the team picking fifth. Is it the same person or is it someone else? Similar names all around.

What I like about this one is the heavy lean on running backs just like we saw in the first draft. The Detroit backfield was secured and then guys like Swift, Jones and Pacheco in the early-middle rounds to complement. The only receiver taken in the first eight picks was Marvin Harrison Jr. but then from Round 9 on it was all receivers, save for Love and Justin Herbert to corner the market with four QBs in total.

The quality of receivers is a mix. Deebo and Reed are going to be decent PPR guys and Matthew Golden offers some explosiveness. But then Luther Burden and Emeka Egbuka both have question marks as they are somewhat buried on their respective depth charts. That’s not to say they won’t be able to pop late in the season like we often see rookies do, but the receiving corps as a whole lacks consistency. Yes, you only need two, maybe three, guys to pop, but he’s also not supplementing his pass-catchers with the tight end position. Dalton Kincaid and Dalton Schultz are position-punt choices with minimal upside. I’ll rank this one-third of the group.

These Beat Bender drafts should be going on throughout training camp, but I am hearing that the contest is filling up pretty quickly. I’ll be looking to do more drafts over the next two months, so if you want to take me on for your chance at $10,000, just click here and I’ll see you in the draft room!

Bender out.

Top Headlines
The Paur Report

Fantasy Life Championship Live Stream (7-16)

Player Notes
Kenneth Walker III Jul 23 8:20pm ET
Kenneth Walker III

Seattle Seahawks running back Kenneth Walker III (ankle) was limited during spring workouts with an ankle injury but was a full-go on Day 1 of training camp on Wednesday. "He looks great. He's in a great spot mentally. Awesome to see him do all the things we want him to do from the get-go. I know he's really excited about what's going on. Great first day with Ken," head coach Mike Macdonald said. An ankle injury limited Walker to one appearance in the last five weeks of the 2024 season, but he appears to be recovered and ready to prove that he's still the team's No. 1 back over Zach Charbonnet. Walker has been plenty productive for fantasy managers when he's been healthy, but the problem is that he always seems to be dealing with a lower-body injury. Seattle could decide to give Charbonnet a bigger role in 2025 to help keep Walker healthy, making him a risk/reward RB2 in fantasy.

From RotoBaller

Kenny Pickett Jul 23 8:20pm ET
Kenny Pickett

The Akron Beacon Journal's Chris Easterling reports that Cleveland Browns quarterback Kenny Pickett spent most of the day on Wednesday in the first training camp practice working with the first-team offense, at least during 11-on-11 drills. However, Pickett went second behind veteran Joe Flacco during modified 7-on-7 work. The Browns have a QB competition going this summer, which is expected to come down to Pickett and Flacco, with rookies Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders mainly looking to prove that the Browns should keep them around beyond 2025. Pickett and Flacco will most likely rotate work with the first team in the early portions of camp. Pickett has mostly been unremarkable in offseason workouts, and Flacco is the favorite to begin the year as the starting QB in Cleveland.

From RotoBaller

Noah Fant Jul 23 8:10pm ET
Noah Fant

The Cincinnati Bengals will host former Seattle Seahawks tight end Noah Fant on a visit on Thursday, sources tell FOX Sports' Jordan Schultz. Fant is making the rounds after being cut by the Seahawks, and the 27-year-old former first-rounder could give Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow another weapon in 2025. Fant wasn't as good the last three years in Seattle -- he had just one touchdown in the last two years -- as he was in his first three years with the Denver Broncos. He never had more than 50 receptions or 500 yards for the Seahawks, but he could give Cincy more depth behind Mike Gesicki with Eric All Jr. (knee) on the PUP list at training camp after tearing his right ACL in Week 9 of last year. Fant would be joining a much more explosive offense if he were to sign with the Bengals, but he wouldn't be guaranteed much of a role alongside Gesicki.

From RotoBaller

Darren Waller Jul 23 6:30pm ET
Darren Waller

Miami Dolphins tight end Darren Waller starting training camp on the Physically Unable to Perform list is standard procedure for players coming out of retirement, according to head coach Mike McDaniel. "You're trying to be responsible. There's no gravity to it. This is a well-conditioned athlete who's in great shape. There's a 0 to 60 element in it that you try to be preventative and responsible as he gets his feet wet, that was our motivation," McDaniel said. The 32-year-old isn't dealing with a specific injury, but the Dolphins aren't going to throw Waller into the fire right away after he didn't play at all in 2024. When the regular season begins, Waller will be the team's top pass-catching tight end, although fantasy managers shouldn't expect him to necessarily put up the numbers Jonnu Smith did in a breakout year in 2024. Still, Waller will be attractive as a TE2 flier, especially in TE-premium leagues.

From RotoBaller

Tommy Tremble Jul 23 6:30pm ET
Tommy Tremble

Carolina Panthers head coach Dave Canales would not say that tight end Tommy Tremble (back) will be back in two weeks at training camp, but he could return in four weeks. Despite starting camp on the Physically Unable to Perform list this week, Tremble is making good progress from back surgery that he had in May. With the 25-year-old out for another couple of weeks at least, it brings into question whether he'll be available for the Week 1 regular-season opener in early September. Even if Tremble is ready to roll by then, he should remain off the fantasy radar in most leagues, as he's mostly known for his blocking and should take a back seat in the pass-catching department to Ja'Tavion Sanders. The former third-rounder in 2021 has never had over 23 catches or 234 yards in his four-year career with the Panthers.

From RotoBaller

Ricky Pearsall Jul 23 6:20pm ET
Ricky Pearsall

The Athletic's Matt Barrows writes that San Francisco 49ers second-year wide receiver Ricky Pearsall (hamstring) trained off on a side field at training camp practice on Wednesday, but he should be back for Sunday's practice. Pearsall began training camp on the Physically Unable to Perform list, but it sounds like he might be activated soon. It's good news for the 49ers with Brandon Aiyuk (knee) potentially not returning until around midseason. In addition, fellow second-year wideout Jacob Cowing injured his hamstring in Wednesday's practice. With Deebo Samuel Sr. now out of town as well, the 24-year-old Pearsall has a major opportunity in 2025 to take the next step if he can stay on the field. If the former first-rounder can put his hamstring issues behind him once and for all, he could be in line for a breakout campaign.

From RotoBaller

Jerome Ford Jul 23 6:20pm ET
Jerome Ford

Cleveland Browns running back Jerome Ford (undisclosed) missed Wednesday's training camp practice with what sounds like a minor undisclosed injury, according to Scott Petrak. However, as Petrak notes, Cleveland's backfield is thin as it is with rookie second-rounder Quinshon Judkins still unsigned as he deals with domestic-violence charges off the field. With Ford dealing with a minor injury, any more time he misses will mean more reps for rookie Dylan Sampson and Pierre Strong Jr. Ahmani Marshall is the only other back on the current roster for the Browns. Judkins' off-field issues are good news for Ford if he's healthy for the start of the season, but the rookie back could still take over most of the backfield work sooner than later. Ford is currently ranked as RotoBaller's RB53, but he'll become much more attractive if Judkins is eventually suspended.

From RotoBaller

Marvin Harrison Jr. Jul 23 6:10pm ET
Marvin Harrison Jr.

PHNX Sports' Bo Brack reports that Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. is listed at 220 pounds at training camp this year on the team's latest roster after last being listed at 209 pounds. It was reportedly earlier this offseason that Harrison appeared to have bulked up, and now we know how much. The 22-year-old from Ohio State had some pretty high expectations placed on him in his first NFL season after being taken fourth overall by the Cardinals. He might not have lived up to most folks' expectations in Year 1, but he still provided 62 receptions for 885 yards and eight touchdowns in 17 games (16 starts) in his rookie campaign. The Cardinals are expecting Harrison to be even better in Year 2, and adding muscle will certainly help him win more downfield. Fantasy managers should target him as a WR2 with upside if he takes the next step.

From RotoBaller

Michael Pittman Jr. Jul 23 6:00pm ET
Michael Pittman Jr.

Indianapolis Colts wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. (knee) took part in the team's first training camp practice on Wednesday, according to the Indianapolis Star's Joel A. Erickson. It's good to hear that Pittman is practicing on the first day of camp after he dealt with some knee soreness on the last day of OTA practices in the spring. The 27-year-old is the team's unquestioned WR1, but it remains to be seen if it will be Daniel Jones or Anthony Richardson Sr. throwing him passes to open the 2025 season in early September. Pittman took a step back in 2024 with a 69-808-3 line in 16 regular-season games (14 starts), primarily because of the turmoil at the QB position. It also didn't help that Josh Downs took a big step forward. He may never see as many targets as he did in 2022 and 2023, and neither Jones nor Richardson will be great for his fantasy value as more of a WR4/flex.

From RotoBaller

Cam Ward Jul 23 5:40pm ET
Cam Ward

Tennessee Titans rookie quarterback Cam Ward, who was the first overall pick in this year's NFL draft, made his training camp debut on Wednesday and took all of the first-team reps, per ESPN's Turron Davenport. Now that Will Levis (shoulder) is out for the entire season while needing surgery on his right shoulder, Ward is firmly in line to start in his first year in the NFL. Back in OTAs and minicamp, the Titans used a rotation of Ward, Levis and Brandon Allen and Tim Boyle. The Titans haven't officially announced Ward as its starter, but it's pretty clear that will eventually come to pass. Davenport goes on to write that most of Ward's passes were towards the middle of the field on Wednesday after most of his success in college came there as well. His first season in the NFL will be more about development and will surely come with plenty of ups and downs. Ward is a low-end QB2 heading into his first year.

From RotoBaller

Chris Godwin Jul 23 5:20pm ET
Chris Godwin

Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Todd Bowles said that there isn't a specific timetable on wide receiver Chris Godwin's (ankle) return, but Bowles also noted he is "on track." Godwin's season ended in Week 7 last year when he suffered a dislocated ankle, and he hasn't been able to practice with the team at all. The 29-year-old was put on the Physically Unable to Perform list this week, although he can be activated at any time during training camp. The Bucs gave Godwin a three-year, $66 million deal back in March, so we'd be a bit surprised if he wasn't ready for Week 1 of the regular season this fall. However, that doesn't necessarily mean he'll be at full speed by then, and he could very easily get off to a slow start if he's eased back in. The longer Godwin sits out in camp, the more of a risk he'll be in fantasy drafts, especially after Tampa took rookie receiver Emeka Egbuka in the first round in April.

From RotoBaller

Will Levis Jul 23 5:10pm ET
Will Levis

The Tennessee Titans placed quarterback Will Levis (shoulder) on Injured Reserve on Wednesday, ending his season, according to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport. It was announced on Monday that Levis would undergo season-ending surgery on his throwing shoulder on July 29. The 26-year-old has decided to have the surgery to ensure his long-term health based on medical opinions, and he should be ready for the start of the 2026 campaign. The problem for Levis is that he didn't look good when given the starting job in 2024, and then the Titans selected Cam Ward with the first overall pick this April. If Ward handles himself well and stays healthy in his first NFL season, Levis will be returning in 2026 and strictly a backup without a chance to regain a starting gig. The surgery also confirms what we already knew: That Ward is the team's starter in 2025.

From RotoBaller

Jalen Hurts Jul 23 5:10pm ET
Jalen Hurts

Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts has picked up where he left off in 2024 in the first day of training camp practice on Wednesday, per Eliot Shorr-Parks. Shorr-Parks writes that Hurts didn't do anything flashy but just showed good overall QB play. He took care of the ball and was never really in harms way while going 14-for-15 passing with no touchdowns or interceptions. Hurts had 26 reps on the day, with Shorr-Parks giving him a B grade. The 26-year-old's best pass of the day was down the sideline to receiver A.J. Brown for a pickup of around 20 yards. Even though Hurts isn't the most accurate or prolific passer, he's ranked as RotoBaller's No. 3 fantasy QB because of his rushing prowess. In the last four seasons over 62 regular-season games, Hurts has 52 rushing touchdowns. It gives him an extremely high fantasy ceiling.

From RotoBaller

Matthew Golden Jul 23 4:20pm ET
Matthew Golden

Green Bay Packers wide receivers Romeo Doubs and Matthew Golden kicked off training camp as the two starters in two-WR sets, according to team reporter Weston Hodkiewicz. While Day 1 training-camp usage should be taken with a grain of salt, this could signal that Jayden Reed will continue to be primarily utilized in three-WR sets. Reed has provided boom weeks for fantasy managers through the first two seasons of his career despite ranking outside the top 70 wide receivers in snap share. It comes as no surprise that Golden, a rookie first-round pick out of Texas, is running with the first team offense, and the team could be hoping he develops into the clear No. 1 wide receiver for Jordan Love. Ultimately, Reed will remain on the fantasy football radar, but his ceiling is limited if Green Bay continues to be unwilling to play him as a full-time receiver.

From RotoBaller

Bo Melton Jul 23 4:10pm ET
Bo Melton

Green Bay Packers fourth-year veteran Bo Melton is officially switching from wide receiver to cornerback, according to NFL.com. The 2022 seventh-round pick out of Rutgers was originally selected by the Seattle Seahawks but signed with Green Bay after being released following training camp. He did not appear in a game during his rookie season, but he has tallied 24 receptions for 309 yards and one touchdown over the last two seasons (22 games). Now at cornerback, he will likely have a tough time earning snaps, but crazier things have happened. Based on these developments, it's safe to drop him in the deepest of dynasty fantasy football leagues

From RotoBaller

Calais Campbell Jul 23 4:00pm ET
Calais Campbell

Arizona Cardinals defensive tackle Walter Nolen (calf) is set to miss time after suffering a calf injury while training, according to head coach Jonathan Gannon. Nolen was the team's first-round pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. It's an unfortunate development for the rookie, who is slated to miss out on the first opportunity to prove himself in training camp. Nolen began his college career at Texas A&M before transferring to Ole Miss for his final season in 2024. In 35 career games, he tallied 114 tackles (62 solo), 11.5 sacks, 26 tackles for loss, four pass deflections, three forced fumbles, and one fumble recovery. He is expected to be a Day 1 starter and disruptor on the Arizona defensive line, but Calais Campbell, PJ Mustipher, Bilal Nichols, Elijah Simmons, and Jordan Burch could see more action with the first- and second-team defenses during his absence.

From RotoBaller

Christian Watson Jul 23 3:50pm ET
Christian Watson

Green Bay Packers wide receiver Christian Watson (knee), who suffered a torn ACL near the end of last season, is recovering well, according to general manager Brian Gutekunst. Gutekunst said his rehab is going "great," and the former North Dakota State speedster did a test run earlier in the week. "It's an ACL, so we're going to take our time with him," Gutekunst said. "But he's pressing to get out there." Watson has missed 13 games through the first three seasons of his pro career since being selected in the second round of the 2022 NFL Draft. Overall, he has hauled in 98 of his 172 targets for 1,653 yards and 14 touchdowns. It's a positive sign that he is recovering quickly, but his fantasy prospects are tough to believe in based on what we've seen thus far and the addition of Texas wideout Matthew Golden in the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft.

From RotoBaller

Jacob Cowing Jul 23 3:40pm ET
Jacob Cowing

San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Jacob Cowing (hamstring) suffered a pulled hamstring during Wednesday's training camp practice, according to head coach Kyle Shanahan. The second-year wideout out of Arizona had a strong spring and is looking to earn a role in 2025, so this is obviously a tough development. However, it is unclear how much practice time Cowing will be forced to sit out, so fantasy managers in deep leagues should monitor the situation. The 2024 fourth-round pick was limited to just four receptions for 80 yards last season in 15 games, but he is a candidate to fill a "gadget" role left behind by Deebo Samuel Sr., who was traded to the Washington Commanders this offseason. With Ricky Pearsall (hamstring) and Brandon Aiyuk (knee) sidelined to begin camp, depth is becoming a concern for the San Fran WR room.

From RotoBaller

Jauan Jennings Jul 23 3:40pm ET
Jauan Jennings

San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Jauan Jennings is participating in Wednesday's training camp practice and is leading the team's wide receivers in drills, according to David Lombardi of The Athletic. Recent reports suggested Jennings wants a new contract and requested a trade, making him a hold-in candidate, but that appears not to be the case. With Ricky Pearsall (hamstring), Brandon Aiyuk (knee), and Jacob Cowing (hamstring) all dealing with injuries, and Deebo Samuel Sr. now in Washington, Jennings has the chance to establish himself as the clear WR1 in the Bay. The former seventh-round pick out of Tennessee set career highs in receptions (77), receiving yards (975), and touchdowns (six) last season in 15 games and could be a 1,000-yard receiver in 2025. Despite the offseason rumors surrounding Jennings, he is a potential steal at his WR40 cost in preseason drafts.

From RotoBaller

Stefon Diggs Jul 23 3:40pm ET
Stefon Diggs

New England Patriots wide receiver Stefon Diggs (knee) was a full participant on Day 1 of training camp. According to Zack Cox of the Boston Herald, Diggs is not feeling any limitations from the ACL tear he suffered last October. He continues to progress in his recovery from his torn ACL and is on target to suit up Week 1 against the Las Vegas Raiders. The veteran joins a Patriots offense desperate for playmakers after finishing last in passing yards (2,995) in 2024. Before the injury, Diggs had recorded six straight 1,000-yard seasons and is expected to lead New England's receiving corps. He'll line up alongside returning contributors Hunter Henry, DeMario Douglas, and third-round rookie Kyle Williams as the Patriots aim to surround quarterback Drake Maye with enough firepower to accelerate his development. Diggs' health will be crucial to any offensive resurgence in New England.

From RotoBaller